As a welcome reprieve from my hectic work life, I walked into the Met’s new Carmen with a mind weighted in skepticism while simultaneously struggling to maintain its openness. Modern productions are not my cup of tea. Revolting staging or not, one thing would be certain: the music would be terrific ! Here, I was delighted. Aigul Akhmetshina, the star out of nowhere, wowed me from the first note of her Habanera, albeit was marred by the hideous chain link fencing that first obscured her from view.

I didn’t hate the new production, which was set in a southern Texas border town replete with cowboys and contraband, but it didn’t resonate with me the way that the directors would have hoped. Some parts felt conceivable, like Escamillo’s spin as a rodeo champion, while others were contrived. Instead of in a cigarette factory, the girls in Act I worked for a weapons manufacturer, wearing pink uniforms. That was lost on me.


I’ve already pontificated about how the Met’s new, modern direction has mostly converted costume designers into professional shoppers (seriously─ all the clothes I saw in Carmen could be bought from Amazon or Goodwill), but it does allow me to create ready to wear garments for my regular wardrobe… or use pieces from my closet ! All of the clothes that I wore for Carmen were either created for other events or bought years ago at a consignment shop. Since cars and trucks were a focal point in Carrie Cracknell’s production, what could be a better photo backdrop than the cars and trucks in my own driveway ?

I wore the pleather pants I had sewn for the 2021 Wagnerians concert and the red scalloped lace bolero that was to resemble Lucia‘s “blood” back in 2022. Both were equally suitable for an edgy, “revved up” Carmen.



A metallic cylinder necklace, which was used in my Queen of the Night outfit for Die Zauberflöte, coincidentally mirrored the tubular LED lights that represented fast-passing highway lights in the production. How cool is that ?!

Despite my ignorance of vehicular matters (I don’t drive), I enjoyed the assembly of automobiles used in the opera. That red Jaguar was saucy !

But I had to settle for a white Chevy pickup truck instead.

Although I was amused by the updated landscape of the new production, I missed the glamour and languid luxury of a more traditional, Sevillian setting. All of these contemporary productions are starting to look the same: chain link fences, barbed wire, Walmart clothes, freakish facial tattoos, the unbathed masses… Hopefully there will one day be a reversal of trends and a renewed appreciation for art as beauty. Opera is too fine to be smothered in exhaust fumes.
Toi, Toi, Toi,
Mary Martha
Cast and Credits:
Carmen ─ Georges Bizet (1875)
Live in HD air date: January 27, 2024
Cast:
Carmen ─ Aigul Akhmetshina
Don José ─ Piotr Beczała
Micaëla ─ Angel Blue
Escamillo ─ Kyle Ketelsen
Credits:
Conductor ─ Daniele Rustioni
Production ─ Carrie Cracknell
Set Designer ─ Michael Levine
Costume Designer ─ Tom Scutt
Lighting Designer ─ Guy Hoare
Projection Designer ─ rocafilm/Roland Hovarth
Choreographer ─ Ann Yee
Live in HD Director ─ Gary Halvorson
Host ─ Matthew Polenzani






























